The Coffees I Keep Coming Back To

The Coffees I Keep Coming Back To

12 November 2026

This is not a best-of list. It is a reorder list. The bags below are the ones I actually buy again, the ones that earned a second bag and then a third. A coffee makes this list by surviving the morning test: would I reach for it again tomorrow?

I used to buy coffee for a living, traveling the world sourcing it and judging it in competitions. These days I drink it at home on a GS3, and the standard is simpler. It has to taste good, it has to be consistent, and it has to be worth the money.

What we cover

  • What earns a reorder
  • The bag that keeps coming back
  • The daily drinker
  • Where I buy
  • What I stopped reordering, and why

What earns a reorder

Three things. First, the cup has to be interesting, not just pleasant. A coffee that tastes fine and forgettable does not get a second bag. Second, it has to brew well more than once. A bag that is great on day three and dull by day ten is a bag with a short window. Third, it has to be worth the price. A great coffee at a silly price is a treat, not a reorder.

Those three filters kill most bags. The ones below passed all three.

The bag that keeps coming back

Presta Ethiopia Koke Honey is the anchor of this list. Honey process, Yirgacheffe, blueberry up front and black tea on the finish. I wrote the full review here: Presta Ethiopia Koke Honey. It is on its third round in my kitchen, which is the highest praise I give a coffee. Most bags get one round. The good ones get two. Three means it is doing something the others are not.

What it does is balance. The honey process gives it sweetness without heaviness, and the Ethiopia character is clear without being loud. It works as espresso and as a pour-over, which matters, because a bag that only works one way is a bag with a short leash.

The daily drinker

Every kitchen needs a daily drinker: the bag that is always there, the one you reach for before you are fully awake. It does not have to be the most exciting coffee you own. It has to be the most reliable one.

My daily drinker changes with the season, and that is the point. The role is fixed, the bag rotates. What stays the same is the job: a coffee that brews well half asleep, tastes good with milk if the morning calls for it, and never makes me wish I had picked something else.

Where I buy

I order from roasters I trust, and Bodhi Leaf is one of them. The orders add up over a year, which is its own kind of review. A roaster you keep ordering from is a roaster that keeps earning it.

Water matters as much as the bag, by the way. I wrote about the espresso water setup here: Espresso Water Filtration: What Actually Matters for Taste. The best coffee in the world tastes flat through bad water.

What I stopped reordering, and why

Two kinds of coffee fall off the list. The first is the bag that was exciting once and never again: a great first cup that faded fast. The second is the bag that was fine but forgettable. Fine is not a reason to reorder. Interesting is.

Price kills a few too. A bag that costs twice the daily drinker has to taste twice as good, and most of them do not.

Final thoughts

A reorder list is a better guide than a best-of list, because it is built from what you actually did, not what you wish you drank. The Koke Honey is the bag that keeps coming back. Everything else has to earn its place the same way: one cup at a time, tomorrow morning.

The short version: Presta Ethiopia Koke Honey is the bag that earned three rounds. The rest of the list is built the same way, one reorder at a time.

/blog/2026-11/coffees-i-keep-coming-back austin.amento.dev